New member with an old question

I have a mealy ’14 Grizz 350 2wd. It’s perfect for my use (hunting) but I do need an update on tires. I’m keeping the stock rims. I need an all around tire but one that isn’t scared of a small amount of mud.

Puncture resistence is as important. Clearly, my rear wheels need to be a tad more aggressive tire Than the fronts. I don’t drive fast, I merely putt around like the old guy I am.

I need advice from you geniuses.