Should I trade???

I have the opportunity to trade my 2002 Scrambler 500 4×4 for one of two Big Red 250es. Both are in phenominal shape, one is mint with original plastics, one is mint with aftermarket plastics. Scrambler is in great shape with some faded plastics. I have other quads to satisfy any utility/family needs, so this one is for me. I rode trikes as a kid, and had a BR awhile ago that I restored, but sold it before I had a chance to take it on the trails (offer was just to good). I guess the question is which one am I going to have more fun on? I ride in New England so trails aren’t really the type where speed is going to be a factor so much as technical fun and of course mud. Thoughts??