Yamaha Fuel Petcock Issue

I replaced the 2 gaskets (happy face ring, and the o-ring) on the Petcock for my 2002 Kodiak 400 ultramatic. Now the knob is very difficult to turn with pliers…near impossible to do with the actual plastic selector knob. I greased the gaskets, but have no idea why it’s so tight.

Does anybody have a picture or links to videos where the order of reassembly is clearly shown? I took it apart a month or two ago and thought I had it all lined up for proper reassembly, but maybe I made a mistake while waiting for the parts?

Sent from my SM-G900W8 using Tapatalk