Starting problems

Hi. New to the forum, so I hope I’m doing this right.
I have a 2003 Honda foreman 500
Actually, I have 2 of them.
I’m Having issues with one. It starts right up using the pull start.
But, when I try the e start all I can hear is the solenoid click. I’ve used a booster pack as well as other batteries and jumper cables.
I’ve also taken the solenoid out of it and put it on my other Honda and it started right up, so I know it’s not the solenoid .
If the starter is shot would the solenoid just click like it is?
Should I remove the starter and put power directly to it and see if it spins?
Or is their something else I should look at first ?
Thanks in advance