Sportsman or RZR?

A weird question, I know. So I currently have a Sportsman 570 SP for ranching and a RZR XP 1000 for play. I bought the RZR so my wife could trail ride with me. I have been building it to ride wooded mountain type trails with slick rocks and creek crossing. But she’s not into it. So now I’m wondering if I should trade it for a Sportsman 1000. The RZR seems like a big expensive unit for just me to trail ride in. The sportsman would be more manuvarble. I’m I crazy for thinking I should switch?