Bought an 09 Grizzly that had fender flares installed and the rear right fender was cracked.

It obviously wasn’t a deal breaker since I bought the atv but now it is bugging me so I’ve got to either:
A) get over it
B) remove fender flares and have to deal with holes
C). Replace fender flares which doesn’t seem great because they will be new and shiny on my not so new bike and new flares seems pricey
D). Find a used matching fender flare

I’d prefer option d but I have no idea how hard it will be to find the same brand of flare ? I wouldn’t be opposed to buying a different used brand but then the hole patterns might be different
Would it look stupid if a different brand was installed on one side or for one flare?

I guess one odd flare would look better than 1 cracked flare. Anyway. Suggestions?