help me decide on tires

Hi, I am putting 26x9x12 tires on my 50" rzr 800. I can’t decide between these two tires. Either bighorn 2.0 or mud light XTR. I ride on your normal trail conditions, not a true mud pit guy. But, I do want a tire that if I come upon a mud hole, I would like to be able to do some light playing. What tire do you recommend and why. Thanks , Chad