’04 Big Bear Rear Fenders Cut (help)

I recently bought a 2004 BB 400 4×4. For some reason, the previous owner cut the rear fenders, and now mud slings all over me and the bike when riding. Anyone know of anyway i can make an extension of the fenders without it looking bad? or should i just go ahead and pay the $120 for new plastic?

Attached Thumbnails

'04 Big Bear Rear Fenders Cut (help)-20151016_160614.jpg
 

'04 Big Bear Rear Fenders Cut (help)-20151016_160610.jpg