Essurance insurance- 2015 xp4 1000

I am with Essurance for my 2011 4 800. With very good coverages 100/300 etc.. I was paying $406 per year for my wife and I. (50+ ages with excellent history) With the same coverages the new quote was over $1900 per year!! Has anyone else experienced a huge difference with Essurance on the 1000 model? I know its a lot more expensive for brand new and being a 1000, but danggggg!!

Will be going to Farmers now.